Pick A Light, Any Light, How Many Can You Find Downtown?
On my last post Brian, a longtime reader and participant, called me out on all this, pointing out that while I’ve written a lot about how things are about to change, details have been scarce.
I agree. Part of this is because not a lot of details have been available. But that’s changing, and this week I’m going to post an entire pdf of what’s being looked at, and issues to consider. First, let’s start with a look at existing conditions.
Downtown’s street lighting is a mess. We have …
Lights that date back to the 1950s like this one. Yes, based on old photos I've seen, we may be looking at an antique here.Sure, internationally reknown architect I.M. Pei is hated, right or wrong, for his role in hundreds of old buildings being torn down. But can't we also hate him for these lights he custom designed as well? Vintage early 1970s. Time to go.At some point these light poles had a distinguishable color. Red maybe? Or purple? I don't know and I can't remember. Now it's just a variation of rust and a reminder of another misguided attempt at modernizing our street appearance. Vintage mid- to late-1970s?
An archeologist could actually use our street lights to record downtown's history. After the box lights, we see no changes in street light designs until the mid-1990s. No coincidence there: downtown development stalled out in the early 1980s and didn't recover until the passage of MAPS in 1993. And it was around 1998 that these "acorn" lights began to appear...
I was in City Engineer Paul Brum's office when he was picking these "vintage-style" acorn street lamps from the OG&E catalog. At the time they were different for sure, and weren't to be found anywhere else. But now they're everywhere. Go to any cookie-cutter northwest OKC or Edmond neighborhood and you'll see these lights. You'll see them all over the suburbs. They say nothing about downtown OKC, and they've become quite suburban and ordinary. And do we really want all of downtown to be cast in a faux vintage design?
Paul Brum had one last pick from the OG&E before retiring (he passed away a few weeks ago). The Pei lights around the convention center were a mess. So Brum went back to the OG&E catalog and picked these globe lights. They can be found around the convention center and some of the adjoining hotels.To get an idea of what's possible, I thought I'd check out Rand Elliott's latest project - The Curve. Sure, we could focus on the architecture, but I wanted to see if Rand was doing anything different with the parking lot lights. And yes, they're different. So what are looking at?
OG&E isn't necessarily the bad guy here. There's an expense involved in manufacturing these lights, and they need a sizeable order to consider manufacturing an entirely different product than what they carry. And that's where we stand today: thanks to the Devon TIF, we can do just that. We can select any light design in the world. We can custom design a light that's found nowhere else. So what have consultants from The Office of James Burnett brought for our review? Well, here's a glimpse of one of the two lights presented last week by designer Derek Boss.
Thank you for joining our conversation on OKC Central. We encourage your discussion but ask that you stay within the bounds of our commenting and posting policy.
Comments
I also wanted to add, Ann Arbor, Michigan has been 100% LED lighting for several years.
http://www.inhabitat.com/2008/01/26/ann-arbor-lighting-up-with-100-leds/
Their supplier of lighting:
Sorry for the triple post, you really should get an edit post button on this blog. One website DEFINITELY worth noting and possibly an article or blog post (would love to see a print article in the sunday oklahoman about this).
The following website talks about and encourages cities to use energy efficient LED lighting, etc.
Here’s some pictures of other LED streetlights:
Houston, TX:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/meltedplastic/3906658381/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/meltedplastic/3907444366/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/meltedplastic/3907440152/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/meltedplastic/3906662865/
Ann Arbor, MI:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/swthomas/3244614106/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/seancadzow/263366013/




I seriously hope they pick NONE of the above, including the ugly one brought by Derek Boss. Frankly whomever is in charge of this, from what I’m seeing and reading on your blog, should be embarrassed. The fact that there is no design competition and public vote or committee is ridiculous. Another lack of foresight by the council and City Manager. It boggles me how naive our city leaders are on so many issues, and even worse, very few citizens in this entire city care to call them out or show up to a council meeting. The minimum requirements for the lights should be solar panels and LED’s. Let’s think about the future if we’re trying to shape it folks!!!